Publisher's Weekly Review
New Yorker Sylvie lives in the shadow of her older sister, Julia, a "virtuosic" ballerina. But Julia is also a drug addict, and after almost dying from an overdose, she disappears. One year later, Sylvie, now a rising ballet star herself, receives a mysterious package containing a volume of fairy tales she lost when she was a child. Clues on the back page indicate that the gift is from her sister, and Sylvie decides to find Julia. Accompanied by her best friend's older brother, who has a car and is willing to travel, Sylvie begins her quest, and suddenly, everything she sees and experiences seems tied to fairy tale figures, particularly heroines in trouble. With a deft hand, McNally (Girls in the Moon) traces the physical and emotional journey of a distressed 16-year-old trying to find answers. Sylvie is forced to confront some harsh truths about her sister and the dance world, but she also finds unexpected compassion and affection from her travel companion. Compelling and slightly surreal, the novel poetically evokes the transformation of a teen whose obsessions affect her perceptions of the world and who has felt imprisoned by others' expectations. Ages 13-up. (Aug.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Horn Book Review
Sixteen-year-old Sylvie ditches her ballet training to search for her older sister Julia, a former ballerina who left town after a career-ending injury. Along the way, Sylvie sees mysterious fairy-tale visions, deals with her own uncertainties about ballet, and falls in love. McNally's prose is an intoxicating blend of witty, magical, and melancholy. The fairy-tale theme entwines gracefully with real-life hope and heartbreak, making this a poignant read. (c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
When a mysterious package offers aspiring ballerina Sylvie a clue regarding her missing older sister's whereabouts, she leaps at the chance to find Julia and bring her home.It's been one year since 16-year-old Sylvie's sister Julia left New York; one year spent trying to fill her shoes at the National Ballet Theatre Academy while everyone pretends Julia didn't overdose on painkillers after a career-ending injury. The only sibling still living at homeartist brother Everett lives in NashvilleSylvie navigates lingering feelings of betrayal, grief, and guilt alone until she discovers a cryptic list of names in her childhood book of fairy tales. Believing this is Julia's call for help, she embarks on a road trip with her best friend's inscrutable older brother, Jack, down the East Coast to find the people on the list and, hopefully, Julia herself. Against a soundtrack of Fleetwood Mac, Sylvie and Jack grow closer, exploring class differences, familial anxieties, and their own distinct identities in the process, but the real love story is between Sylvie and her siblings. McNally's (Girls in the Moon, 2016, etc.) vivid imagery and exquisite, poetic languagewith an ever so slightly sinister undercurrentweave shimmering, slow-building tension throughout. Most major characters appear straight and white, but some secondary characters are people of color and gay men.This ode to sisterhood and strength leads up to an unexpected and thoroughly satisfying conclusion. (resources) (Fiction. 13-18) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
*Starred Review* As far back as Sylvie can remember, her older sister, Julia, was the star, drawing attention at their prestigious ballet academy and in life. But then came Julia's accident, her painkiller addiction, and then, finally, her disappearance, leaving Sylvie to carry on in ballet and in life alone. When a long-lost copy of a book of fairy tales shows up in the mail with enigmatic doodles on its end pages, Sylvie knows it's from Julia, but it's a cryptic map at best. Then Sylvie starts crossing paths with people too similar to fairy tale characters to be coincidental. Convinced she's losing her mind, Sylvie reluctantly enlists the help of her best friend's brother, who comes equipped with an ancient Volvo and a Fleetwood Mac playlist, and blows off ballet camp for a road trip across the Eastern Seaboard to find her sister. If Julia truly wants to be found, however, remains to be seen, and even if she is found, whether or not she can be saved may not be up to Sylvie. In her sophomore offering, McNally (Girls in the Moon, 2016) puts not a single note out of place. Similar in concept, though softer in tone, to Melissa Albert's The Hazel Wood (2018), this is a precise, musical novel that's extraordinarily effective in format. A bittersweet modern fairy tale, tinged with magical realism, that will touch hearts.--Reagan, Maggie Copyright 2018 Booklist
