Library Journal Review

Dershowitz, building on the popularity of his previous work The Case for Israel, outlines what he considers "the obvious solution" to the conflict in the Middle East, a variation of the "two state" plan. Starting with the premise that the Palestinian community is moving toward a peaceful, democratic society, he lists all the advantages that would arise from the adaptation of his plan. Unfortunately, since the book was written, it has become obvious that coexistence with Israel is still unacceptable to the current Palestinian leadership and others in the Muslim world. Therefore, what the author is proposing is a "separate peace," and a "separate peace" is no peace at all. In addition, he undermines his own authority by inserting a highly inappropriate polemic about individuals who attacked his previous book and/or are strongly anti-Israel. The result is a work that is divisive rather than insightful, praised by those who already share his beliefs and demonized by those who oppose them. Dershowitz's regional accent may initially surprise some listeners, but he is clear and expressive. Well read but disappointing; recommended for large collections only.-I. Pour-El, Des Moines Area Community Coll., Boone, IA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.