School Library Journal Review
Gr 3-5-A tender story about love and loss. Anna Maria, the nine-year-old daughter of a gifted violin maker, is sent to live and study at the Pieta, an orphanage in Venice, after her father dies. The violin prodigy flourishes under the tutelage of maestro Antonio Vivaldi but suffers a devastating blow when a jealous classmate throws her precious violin into a canal. What follows is a compelling lesson in selflessness and forgiveness. Shefelman's style is light, simple, and pleasing, and she has placed a cast of likable characters in a lovely setting. There is a brief glossary of musical and religious terms as well as a closing note about the actual Pieta and Vivaldi's stint as an instructor there, making this a good cross-curricular tool in addition to an engaging read.-Alyson Low, Fayetteville Public Library, AR (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Horn Book Review
In eighteenth-century Italy, Anna Maria's dying father makes her a violin to remember him by. When Anna Maria goes to live with the nuns and the composer Vivaldi in a Venice orphanage, a jealous girl throws the precious violin into a canal. Shefelman's character and plot development are a touch simplistic but make the book more appropriate for the age group. Text includes a historical note. Glos. (c) Copyright 2010. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. All rights reserved.
Kirkus Review
Shortly after her father's death, Anna Maria is sent to study violin at the Piet, an orphanage and music school for girls in Venice. She is welcomed by a new friend, Silvia, but victimized by a talented but jealous fellow violinist, Paolina. The composer Antonio Vivaldi teaches both girls, and they vie for the same solos. In a fit of jealousy, Paolina takes Anna Maria's beloved violina last gift from her fatherand drops it into a nearby Venetian canal. Anna Maria searches for her treasured instrument while Paolina pays for this act of passion. A fascinating view of 18th-century Venice with its vibrant music scene, this novel explores the powers of friendship and forgiveness. The simply told tale, with its direct plot and characterizations, is suited to younger readers than Pat Lowery Collins's Hidden Voices (2009), with which it shares a setting. The secondary charactersthe gondolier, the sisters of the Piet and the wealthy merchant who ends up with Anna Maria's violinadd much to this offering for independent readers who love history. Papp's illustrations not seen. (Historical fiction. 6-9)]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Like Emily Arnold McCully's picture book The Orphan Singer (2001) and Pat Lowery Collins' young-adult novel HiddenVoices(2009), this illustrated chapter book is set in the eighteenth-century Venetian orphanage where Antonio Vivaldi instructed girls in music. Anna Maria's father, a renowned violin maker, expresses a dying wish for her to enter the Pietà Orphanage. There she finds a good friend in Sylvia and a fierce enemy in jealous Paolina. Worried when her beloved violin disappears, and enraged when she learns that Paolina threw it into the canal, Sylvia must rely on the power of music as well as self-control, courage, and forgiveness to make things right again. More memorable than the somewhat idealized ending are the strong emotions that lie at the heart of the story. While the final art was not seen, the sketches look promising, and the jacket is well designed to draw children intrigued by the historical setting or the musical theme. A glossary and a historical note are appended to this short, appealing historical novel from the Stepping Stone series.--Phelan, Carolyn Copyright 2010 Booklist
