Publisher's Weekly Review
In disorganized fashion, journalist Doherty (Radicals for Capitalism) tries to explain how Paul and his supporters-"homeschooling Christians and couch-surfing punk rockers, college professors and famous actors"-are "changing the shape of American politics." Doherty attempts to frame Paul in a historical context by tracing the argument for a "separation of government from banking" as far back as the Van Buren administration, while also comparing Paul to William Jennings Bryan, suggesting that "the two politicians' character, style, populist appeal, and most specifically their anti-imperialism mark them as kin." Though Paul's recollections about marrying his high school sweetheart, getting drafted in 1962, and, as a doctor, seeing "an infant [that] was put in the trash and left to die" provide the book's most compelling passages, a full picture never emerges. Instead, Doherty rehashes existing accounts of Paul's first House election in 1976, hastily mentions Paul's 1988 presidential campaign on the Libertarian ticket, and rushes through the next 20 years to his 2008 Republican presidential campaign. The chapters mostly proceed chronologically, but without any coherent, compelling structure or narrative. In a too transparent effort to link the book with Paul's 2012 presidential campaign, Doherty briefly summarizes the Iowa and New Hampshire primaries and concludes, "Paulites will represent [the] future," though how or why Doherty makes this claim remains unclear. Agent: William Clark, William Clark Associates. (May) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Kirkus Review
A breezy and generally admiring though not hagiographic look at the quixotic fixture at the far-right extreme of the last couple of presidential elections. Reason editor Doherty (Gun Control on Trial: Inside the Supreme Court Battle Over the Second Amendment, 2009, etc.) would seem to share Ron Paul's libertarian leanings, though he professes some amusement and bewilderment at Paul's tactics, if not his message. Paul, for instance, has often spoken of terrorist activities as the blowback attendant in our messing around in other countries' business, to which Doherty responds, presumably channeling Joe Six-Pack, "Whoa--a history lesson, recognizing consequences to our actions, an empathetic approach to what the rest of the world would think?" The rhetorical trick gets a little old, but it's clear that Doherty cares greatly about capturing what Paul's supporters think about him and his ideas and, moreover, that he cares about representing them fairly. Much of the narrative is thus given over to fan notes, as against the words of the supposedly elite media. Not that the fan base is huge to begin with: "Paul's rigorous hewing to a vision of government that almost every part of America's learned political, academic, and media elites considers silly was only the start of his problems with the American electorate." Doherty offers considerable insight into some aspects of Paul's ongoing presidential campaigns. The chances of his ever being elected, after all, are vanishingly small, but one desired effect might be the opportunity to influence the choice of vice president, as he might have in 2008. Yet Paul, a maverick if nothing else, keeps his own counsel, insisting, for instance, on giving lessons in Austrian economic theory and demanding the abolition of the Federal Reserve rather than sharpening crowd-pleasing attacks on America's foreign wars and the ill-advised war on drugs at home. Illuminating, if sometimes a chore to read, and a welcome aid to understanding the evolution of Paul's offbeat ideas.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Paul, a congressman from Texas, has political views that are not exactly in alignment with either of the two major parties. He takes what is generally considered a liberal position on the war on drugs and war in the Middle East but a decidedly conservative stance on ending income taxes, the IRS, and the Federal Reserve. An obstetrician and air force veteran, Paul is a follower of libertarians, most prominently F. A. Hayek. Doherty, himself a libertarian and the author of This Burning Man (2004), met Paul during his first run for the presidency in 1988 under the Libertarian Party banner and portrays a man who is difficult to define politically and who is frank and honest to the point of political suicide. In a debate with Rudy Giuliani during the 2008 presidential contest, Paul called the 9/11 terrorist attack a reaction to the provocation of American involvement in the Middle East. Noting Paul's enormously diverse followers, Doherty compares Paul to Barry Goldwater and Eugene McCarthy as he argues that Paul and his free-market liberation ideals will have a lasting impact on American politics.--Bush, Vanessa Copyright 2010 Booklist
