Publisher's Weekly Review
It's difficult to determine whether Fishbeyn's doorstop debut is intended to be a diverting contemporary romance or a melodramatic polemic against anti-Semitism. The first-person narrative of Russian Jewish émigré Emma reveals a self-indulgent navel-gazer who is both grandiloquent and romantic. The romantic part withers a bit when her interfering grandmother sets her up with the ostensibly perfect match: Alexei Bagdanovich, who's a Russian Jew, a Princeton man, and determined to remain chaste until marriage. That's not exactly ideal for this newly minted American feminist who shed her birth name, Lena Kabelmacher, quicker than you could say "Emma Kaulfield." Liberated as she professes to be, behind Emma's American face lurk Lena's roots. As she indulges in a no-strings affair with dashing gentile Eddie Beltrafio, the voices of her ancestors nibble away at her so-called liberated resolve. Occasional laugh-out-loud moments provide respite from the avalanche of angsty, guilt-heavy, conscience-cleansing prose. Agent: Don Fehr, Trident Media Group. (May) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Kirkus Review
A Russian-Jewish immigrant has a tempestuous and life-altering fling with an American investment banker in Fishbeyn's debut.Russian native Elena "Lenochka" Kabelmacher changed her name to Emma Kaulfield because it sounded more American. Her parents and grandmother, Russian Jews who, after a struggle with the KGB, were able to emigrate with Emma and her sister to the U.S., are now, in the late 1990s, wealthy Chicago suburbanites. Emma's grandmother, the undisputed family tyrant and sage, has decreed that 20-something Emma will pursue a high-achievement career track, studying statistics at N.Y.U. rather than following her true passion, painting. Emma is terrible at statistics, both in academe (she's flunking) and real life, where she fails to appreciate the odds against finding true love in the ladies' room of La Cote Basque. Ineffably drawn to a complete stranger with whom she makes out in that very bathroom, Emma assumes that will be the end of it. Then, on an outing with her fiance, fellow migr Alex (a match made by Grandmother), she re-encounters the stranger: he is Eddie, Alex's colleague. As she and Alex plan an elaborate Chicago wedding, she and Eddie fall inexorably back into one another's arms. What's a girl to do? Eddie promises to support her and let her paint to her heart's content, but Emma wants to be financially independent; she just isn't sure how. The most interesting sections of the novel depict family encounters, both in Moscow flashbacks and in '90s Winnetka, wherein the Kabelmachers and their friends one-up each other, overshare, and squabble in two languages, never failing to demonstrate fierce loyalty and unconditional if domineering love. Contrast this with Eddie's family, which is dysfunctional in a different way ( la Tolstoy?), withholding, undermining, and uncommunicative. What elevates this above the standard rom-com is the language, idiosyncratic, inventive, and ornate, although Fishbeyn's word choices, overworked and/or a little off, often read like a slightly out-of-kilter translation. A cacophonous but compelling new voice. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
At 24, Emma Kaulfield, formerly Lena Kabelmacher, lives in New York City. Miserably enrolled in a graduate stats program, she's also juggling the expectations of her immigrant Jewish-Russian family, who are mortified by her single status. When Emma is set up with Alex, son of a family friend and up-and-coming businessman, it seems to be a perfect match. On the night of their engagement, however, Emma has a passionate encounter with a handsome stranger. She later meets the mystery man, Eddie, at a gallery opening, and the two embark on an affair. Emma quickly finds herself caught between two worlds, that of Alex, who provides security and stability, and that of Eddie, who emboldens her to follow her true desires. At the same time, Emma must deal with the pressures to be a perfect immigrant child as well as haunting childhood memories of Soviet Russia. Soon enough, these contrasting worlds collide. Fishbeyn's thoughtful debut offers an in-depth exploration into an individual's struggles with conflicting desires and expectations as well as a distinctive perspective on the immigrant experience.--Strauss, Leah Copyright 2010 Booklist
